| Peek | 401 | Rare | — | — | $10.05 | $9.08 |
| Peer into the Abyss (2002) (Rainbow Foil) | 2002 | Rare | — | — | $11.76 | $8.33 |
| Peer into the Abyss (2021) (Rainbow Foil) | 2021 | Rare | — | — | $8.00 | $7.18 |
| Peregrine Drake (Rainbow Foil) | 1488 | Rare | — | — | $32.26 | $32.09 |
| Pernicious Deed (Rainbow Foil) | 1777 | Rare | — | — | $4.81 | $4.67 |
| Perplexing Chimera | 7039 | Rare | — | — | $3.25 | $2.06 |
| Persistent Petitioners (593) | 593 | Rare | — | — | $40.95 | $37.23 |
| Persistent Petitioners (595) | 595 | Rare | — | — | $540.00 | $540.00 |
| Persistent Petitioners (596) | 596 | Rare | — | — | $48.50 | $42.47 |
| Persistent Petitioners (597) | 597 | Rare | — | — | $32.90 | $30.58 |
| Persistent Petitioners (598) | 598 | Rare | — | — | $129.18 | $125.31 |
| Persistent Petitioners (599) | 599 | Rare | — | — | $19.77 | $18.13 |
| Persistent Petitioners (600) | 600 | Rare | — | — | $160.00 | $133.12 |
| Persistent Petitioners (601) | 601 | Rare | — | — | $39.99 | $32.51 |
| Phage the Untouchable | 1195 | Mythic | — | — | $66.00 | $63.11 |
| Pharika, God of Affliction | 82 | Mythic | — | — | $9.81 | $9.04 |
| Phenax, God of Deception | 75 | Mythic | — | — | $31.83 | $30.64 |
| Phyrexian Arena (Confetti Foil) | 2333 | Rare | — | — | $24.06 | $21.58 |
| Phyrexian Arena (Rainbow Foil) | 2318 | Rare | — | — | $14.00 | $11.57 |
| Phyrexian Crusader (Retro Frame) | 847 | Promo | — | — | $10.05 | $7.48 |
| Phyrexian Crusader (Step-and-Compleat Foil) | 1214 | Rare | — | — | $19.99 | $19.34 |
| Phyrexian Metamorph (Rainbow Foil) | 1758 | Rare | — | — | $16.30 | $13.27 |
| Phyrexian Unlife (Step-and-Compleat Foil) | 1213 | Rare | — | — | $13.99 | $11.32 |
| Piko Piko Hammer - Hammer of Nazahn (Rainbow Foil) | 2098 | Rare | — | — | $10.49 | $9.40 |
| Pilgrim's Eye (Borderless) | 692 | Rare | — | — | $6.90 | $5.94 |
| Piper of the Swarm | 7074 | Rare | — | — | $3.99 | $3.04 |
| Pitiless Plunderer (Rainbow Foil) | 1431 | Rare | — | — | $23.22 | $19.94 |
| Plague Engineer (Step-and-Compleat Foil) | 1215 | Rare | — | — | $7.00 | $6.31 |
| Plague Sliver (Extended Art) | 633 | Rare | — | — | $1.88 | $1.50 |
| Plague Sliver (Extended Art) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) | 633 | Rare | — | — | $15.20 | $10.82 |
| Plaguecrafter (Borderless) (Foil Etched) | 1116 | Rare | — | — | $37.53 | $30.77 |
| Plains (0888) (Rainbow Foil) | 888 | Rare | — | — | $9.50 | $8.58 |
| Plains (1348) | 1348 | Land | — | — | $0.49 | $0.41 |
| Plains (1349) | 1349 | Land | — | — | $0.58 | $0.50 |
| Plains (1350) | 1350 | Land | — | — | $0.50 | $0.37 |
| Plains (1351) | 1351 | Land | — | — | $0.50 | $0.42 |
| Plains (1478) (Rainbow Foil) | 1478 | Rare | — | — | $5.49 | $4.91 |
| Plains (1513) | 1513 | Rare | — | — | $5.17 | $4.54 |
| Plains (1647) (Rainbow Foil) | 1647 | Rare | — | — | $18.71 | $12.62 |
| Plains (1652) (Rainbow Foil) | 1652 | Rare | — | — | $9.49 | $7.80 |
| Plains (1939) (Rainbow Foil) | 1939 | Rare | — | — | $4.15 | $3.45 |
| Plains (1945) (Rainbow Foil) | 1945 | Rare | — | — | $11.50 | $10.97 |
| Plains (1950) (Raised Foil) | 1950 | Rare | — | — | $11.70 | $9.40 |
| Plains (2076) (Rainbow Foil) | 2076 | Rare | — | — | $3.60 | $2.76 |
| Plains (2441) | 2441 | Rare | — | — | $8.39 | $7.50 |
| Plains (2754) | 2754 | Rare | $10.49 | — | $36.97 | — |
| Plains (540) | 540 | Land | — | — | $5.66 | $4.70 |
| Plains (541) | 541 | Land | — | — | $1.50 | $1.47 |
| Plains (542) | 542 | Land | — | — | $3.41 | $2.39 |
| Plains (543) | 543 | Land | — | — | $11.86 | $10.03 |