| Sam, Loyal Attendant (Extended Art) | 90 | Mythic | $3.62 | $3.62 | $5.22 | $5.26 |
| Champions of Minas Tirith (Showcase Scrolls) | 412 | Rare | $3.58 | $3.58 | $5.08 | $4.02 |
| Shelob, Dread Weaver (Extended Art) | 112 | Rare | $3.75 | $3.57 | — | — |
| Merry, Warden of Isengard (Showcase Scrolls) | 468 | Rare | $4.95 | $3.56 | $10.86 | $8.61 |
| Sol Ring | 284 | Uncommon | $3.48 | $3.56 | — | — |
| Haldir, Lorien Lieutenant (Extended Art) | 122 | Rare | $3.06 | $3.47 | — | — |
| Monstrosity of the Lake (Showcase Scrolls) | 424 | Rare | $3.75 | $3.47 | $6.00 | $4.94 |
| Haldir, Lorien Lieutenant (Showcase Scrolls) | 441 | Rare | $4.59 | $3.46 | $4.88 | $4.77 |
| Crown of Gondor (Extended Art) | 155 | Rare | $3.42 | $3.45 | — | — |
| Lossarnach Captain (Showcase Scrolls) | 418 | Rare | $3.42 | $3.42 | $5.97 | $4.40 |
| Explore (Borderless) | 528 | Uncommon | $3.50 | $3.40 | $3.72 | $3.44 |
| Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles (Showcase Scrolls) | 417 | Rare | $5.57 | $3.35 | $7.02 | $5.85 |
| Radagast, Wizard of Wilds (Showcase Scrolls) | 473 | Rare | $3.35 | $3.34 | $3.67 | $3.63 |
| Orcish Siegemaster (Extended Art) | 116 | Rare | $3.38 | $3.31 | — | — |
| Cirdan the Shipwright (Showcase Scrolls) | 453 | Rare | $3.30 | $3.27 | $7.40 | $6.44 |
| Supreme Verdict | 272 | Rare | $3.16 | $3.27 | — | — |
| Notion Thief | 270 | Rare | $3.25 | $3.24 | — | — |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard (Extended Art) | 146 | Rare | $3.74 | $3.23 | — | — |
| Well of Lost Dreams | 291 | Rare | $3.19 | $3.22 | — | — |
| Anguished Unmaking | 265 | Rare | $3.11 | $3.18 | — | — |
| Legolas Greenleaf (Extended Art) | 123 | Rare | $3.15 | $3.15 | — | — |
| Lossarnach Captain (Extended Art) | 100 | Rare | $3.11 | $3.15 | — | — |
| Elvish Warmaster | 241 | Rare | $3.47 | $3.12 | — | — |
| Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant (Extended Art) | 131 | Rare | $2.98 | $3.11 | — | — |
| Isengard Unleashed (Borderless) | 495 | Rare | $3.06 | $3.09 | $2.51 | $2.21 |
| Hithlain Rope (Showcase Scrolls) | 486 | Rare | $2.92 | $2.94 | $4.80 | $2.23 |
| Moria Scavenger (Extended Art) | 145 | Rare | $2.84 | $2.94 | — | — |
| Feasting Hobbit (Extended Art) | 120 | Rare | $2.89 | $2.88 | — | — |
| Monstrosity of the Lake (Extended Art) | 105 | Rare | $2.88 | $2.88 | — | — |
| Summons of Saruman (Showcase Scrolls) | 480 | Rare | $2.94 | $2.88 | $4.68 | $3.40 |
| Sulfurous Springs | 334 | Rare | $2.87 | $2.87 | — | — |
| Whispersilk Cloak | 292 | Uncommon | $2.91 | $2.75 | — | — |
| Eomer, King of Rohan (Extended Art) | 135 | Rare | $2.72 | $2.72 | — | — |
| Witch-king, Sky Scourge (Borderless) | 511 | Mythic | $2.80 | $2.72 | $2.50 | $2.23 |
| Farmer Cotton | 55 | Rare | $2.75 | $2.65 | — | — |
| Trap the Trespassers (Showcase Scrolls) | 427 | Rare | $2.36 | $2.62 | $1.30 | $1.24 |
| Gilraen, Dunedain Protector (Extended Art) | 97 | Rare | $2.65 | $2.52 | — | — |
| Summons of Saruman (Extended Art) | 150 | Rare | $2.50 | $2.50 | — | — |
| Wake the Dragon (Showcase Scrolls) | 484 | Rare | $3.00 | $2.45 | $4.21 | $4.21 |
| Gollum, Obsessed Stalker (Extended Art) | 109 | Rare | $2.50 | $2.40 | — | — |
| Aragorn, King of Gondor (Extended Art) | 85 | Mythic | $2.46 | $2.39 | $2.75 | $2.73 |
| Blasphemous Act | 211 | Rare | $2.38 | $2.38 | — | — |
| Faramir, Steward of Gondor (Showcase Scrolls) | 458 | Rare | $2.69 | $2.37 | $6.04 | $5.30 |
| Field-Tested Frying Pan (Showcase Scrolls) | 413 | Rare | $2.33 | $2.37 | $2.15 | $2.15 |
| Lothlorien Blade (Showcase Scrolls) | 487 | Rare | $3.07 | $2.35 | $3.99 | $3.59 |
| Overwhelming Stampede | 254 | Rare | $2.80 | $2.35 | — | — |
| Banquet Guests (Extended Art) | 130 | Rare | $2.27 | $2.27 | — | — |
| Assemble the Entmoot (Showcase Scrolls) | 438 | Rare | $3.98 | $2.26 | $5.70 | $5.42 |
| Song of Earendil (Showcase Scrolls) | 479 | Rare | $2.22 | $2.26 | $3.05 | $3.05 |
| Faramir, Steward of Gondor (Extended Art) | 137 | Rare | $2.25 | $2.25 | — | — |