| Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit (Showcase Scrolls) | 461 | Mythic | $20.25 | $16.62 | $102.05 | $68.32 |
| The Black Gate (Extended Art) | 160 | Rare | $17.06 | $16.31 | — | — |
| Second Harvest (Borderless) | 530 | Rare | $16.65 | $15.75 | $19.19 | $17.29 |
| Nazgul Battle-Mace (Borderless) | 510 | Rare | $18.98 | $15.52 | $16.40 | $14.95 |
| Raise the Palisade (Extended Art) | 106 | Rare | $16.67 | $15.52 | — | — |
| Galadhrim Ambush (Showcase Scrolls) | 440 | Rare | $17.03 | $15.48 | $25.72 | $20.34 |
| Stonehewer Giant (Borderless) | 521 | Rare | $16.14 | $15.46 | $19.99 | $16.11 |
| Three Rings for the Elven-Kings - Rings of Brighthearth (Borderless) | 352 | Mythic | $14.99 | $14.81 | $16.15 | $15.49 |
| Eowyn, Shieldmaiden (Showcase Scrolls) | 456 | Mythic | $18.00 | $14.15 | $46.44 | $27.49 |
| Aragorn, King of Gondor (Showcase Scrolls) | 448 | Mythic | $15.00 | $13.89 | $35.00 | $30.63 |
| Forth Eorlingas! (Showcase Scrolls) | 460 | Rare | $14.50 | $13.78 | $31.87 | $28.63 |
| The Gaffer (Showcase Scrolls) | 414 | Rare | $13.73 | $13.73 | $20.77 | $20.77 |
| Sauron, Lord of the Rings (Showcase Scrolls) | 478 | Mythic | $17.99 | $13.68 | $32.09 | $21.27 |
| Green Dragon Inn - Homeward Path (Borderless) | 365 | Mythic | $14.50 | $13.17 | $14.33 | $13.65 |
| In the Darkness Bind Them (Showcase Scrolls) | 465 | Rare | $13.70 | $12.74 | $33.95 | $28.64 |
| Raise the Palisade | 23 | Rare | $12.63 | $12.63 | — | — |
| Swan Song | 197 | Rare | $13.14 | $12.51 | — | — |
| Lord of the Nazgul (Extended Art) | 142 | Rare | $14.49 | $12.49 | — | — |
| Bridge of Khazad-dum - Ensnaring Bridge (Borderless) | 350 | Mythic | $13.99 | $12.36 | $14.49 | $14.11 |
| Gimli of the Glittering Caves | 32 | Rare | $13.42 | $12.21 | — | — |
| Treebeard, Gracious Host (Showcase Scrolls) | 483 | Rare | $13.99 | $12.01 | $23.69 | $21.78 |
| Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress (Borderless) | 514 | Rare | $15.30 | $11.97 | $11.77 | $10.75 |
| Essence Warden | 242 | Common | $12.09 | $11.95 | — | — |
| Relic of Sauron (Extended Art) | 159 | Rare | $13.66 | $11.93 | — | — |
| Elessar, the Elfstone - Cloudstone Curio (Borderless) | 349 | Mythic | $13.98 | $11.45 | $13.04 | $12.07 |
| Birds of Paradise | 235 | Rare | $11.70 | $11.15 | — | — |
| The Black Gate | 80 | Rare | $10.83 | $10.56 | — | — |
| Galadhrim Ambush (Extended Art) | 121 | Rare | $10.86 | $10.54 | — | — |
| Taunt from the Rampart (Showcase Scrolls) | 481 | Rare | $11.69 | $10.48 | $20.07 | $16.09 |
| Bag End - Horizon Canopy (Borderless) | 366 | Mythic | $11.29 | $10.34 | $10.49 | $10.25 |
| Reanimate | 206 | Rare | $10.60 | $10.30 | — | — |
| Anduril, Narsil Reforged (Borderless) | 491 | Rare | $11.60 | $10.13 | $10.49 | $9.64 |
| Seasons Past (Borderless) | 529 | Rare | $10.57 | $9.88 | $23.92 | $21.84 |
| Soul's Attendant (Borderless) | 520 | Uncommon | $11.13 | $9.88 | $12.93 | $12.27 |
| Galadhrim Brigade (Borderless) | 502 | Rare | $13.04 | $9.84 | $10.00 | $7.85 |
| Relic of Sauron | 79 | Rare | $9.88 | $9.08 | — | — |
| Taunt from the Rampart (Extended Art) | 151 | Rare | $9.26 | $8.96 | — | — |
| Arwen, Weaver of Hope (Extended Art) | 118 | Rare | $9.07 | $8.82 | — | — |
| Shelob, Dread Weaver (Showcase Scrolls) | 431 | Rare | $8.62 | $8.79 | $8.33 | $8.01 |
| Weathertop - Deserted Temple (Borderless) | 363 | Mythic | $9.01 | $8.78 | $9.31 | $8.04 |
| Rammas Echor, Ancient Shield (Borderless) | 505 | Rare | $8.78 | $8.36 | $7.25 | $5.83 |
| Gimli's Reckless Might (Borderless) | 494 | Rare | $8.82 | $8.32 | $6.10 | $5.69 |
| The Gaffer (Extended Art) | 96 | Rare | $9.88 | $8.03 | — | — |
| Meduseld, Golden Hall of Edoras - Castle Ardenvale (Borderless) | 361 | Mythic | $8.30 | $7.74 | $7.99 | $7.18 |
| Grima, Saruman's Footman (Showcase Scrolls) | 464 | Rare | $7.50 | $7.50 | $11.69 | $11.59 |
| Inn of the Prancing Pony - Pillar of the Paruns (Borderless) | 372 | Mythic | $7.45 | $7.43 | $6.58 | $6.03 |
| Forth Eorlingas! (Extended Art) | 139 | Rare | $8.33 | $7.30 | — | — |
| Olorin's Searing Light (Borderless) | 503 | Rare | $7.30 | $7.30 | $6.43 | $6.04 |
| The Gaffer | 12 | Rare | $7.62 | $7.28 | — | — |
| Asceticism | 233 | Rare | $7.19 | $7.18 | — | — |