| Seven Dwarves (0818) (Rainbow Foil) | 818 | Rare | — | — | $37.07 | $36.75 |
| Seven Dwarves (0819) | 819 | Rare | — | — | $48.06 | $45.57 |
| Shadow Sliver (Extended Art) | 624 | Rare | — | — | $5.35 | $4.50 |
| Shadow the Hedgehog (Rainbow Foil) | 2086 | Mythic | — | — | $6.62 | $5.98 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (680) | 680 | Rare | — | — | $47.00 | $40.83 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (681) | 681 | Rare | — | — | $21.76 | $21.49 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (681) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) | 681 | Rare | — | — | $168.27 | $148.98 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (682) | 682 | Rare | — | — | $72.99 | $41.79 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (683) | 683 | Rare | — | — | $71.00 | $71.00 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (684) | 684 | Rare | — | — | $92.00 | $75.84 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (685) | 685 | Rare | — | — | $463.11 | $462.91 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (686) | 686 | Rare | — | — | $12.99 | $12.64 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (687) | 687 | Rare | — | — | $15.00 | $11.67 |
| Shadowborn Apostle (688) | 688 | Rare | — | — | $92.91 | $85.18 |
| Shadrix Silverquill | 2130 | Mythic | — | — | $3.69 | $2.74 |
| Shaman of the Pack (Extended Art) | 789 | Rare | — | — | $7.70 | $7.25 |
| Shapeshifter Token (1906) (Double Rainbow Foil) | 1906 | Token | — | — | $3.55 | $1.75 |
| Shapeshifter Token (1907) (Double Rainbow Foil) | 1907 | Token | — | — | $2.99 | $1.38 |
| Shapeshifter Token (1908) (Double Rainbow Foil) | 1908 | Token | — | — | $2.69 | $1.45 |
| Shapeshifter Token (1909) (Double Rainbow Foil) | 1909 | Token | — | — | $3.00 | $1.71 |
| Shared Summons (Rainbow Foil) | 1308 | Rare | — | — | $2.69 | $2.07 |
| Shattergang Brothers (Rainbow Foil) | 1315 | Mythic | — | — | $11.67 | $9.48 |
| Sheldon, the Commander - Ruhan of the Fomori (Rainbow Foil) | 1695 | Mythic | — | — | $1.15 | $0.91 |
| Shelter (Rainbow Foil) | 1587 | Rare | — | — | $17.52 | $15.95 |
| Shield of War and Peace - Sword of War and Peace (Rainbow Foil) | 1730 | Mythic | — | — | $16.60 | $14.76 |
| Shiva - Subtlety (Rainbow Foil) | 7005 | Mythic | — | — | $1,092.30 | $1,002.28 |
| Shivan Dragon (1709) (Rainbow Foil) | 1709 | Rare | — | — | $4.00 | $3.38 |
| Shivan Dragon (Serial Numbered) | 716 | Promo | $1,849.96 | — | — | — |
| Shorikai, Genesis Engine (Rainbow Foil) | 1880 | Mythic | — | — | $22.77 | $19.34 |
| Shrine Token (Rainbow Foil) | 1835 | Token | — | — | $9.68 | $7.96 |
| Shu Jing Meteorite - Fellwar Stone (Rainbow Foil) | 7062 | Rare | — | — | $11.25 | $10.25 |
| Sidewinder Sliver (Extended Art) | 615 | Rare | — | — | $1.59 | $1.26 |
| Sigarda's Aid | 731 | Rare | — | — | $65.86 | $63.92 |
| Silence (0881) (Black & White Foil) | 881 | Rare | — | — | $150.25 | $114.24 |
| Silence (1816) (Rainbow Foil) | 1816 | Rare | — | — | $18.31 | $14.35 |
| Silence (2300) (Rainbow Foil) | 2300 | Rare | — | — | $19.39 | $16.08 |
| Silver Shroud Costume | 915 | Promo | — | — | $12.71 | $9.85 |
| Simian Spirit Guide (Rainbow Foil) | 1548 | Rare | — | — | $124.99 | $109.65 |
| Simic Ascendancy (Rainbow Foil) | 1832 | Rare | — | — | $14.99 | $13.35 |
| Simic Signet (Foil Etched) | 295 | Rare | — | — | $17.36 | $14.35 |
| Six | 2660 | Rare | — | — | $20.06 | $17.43 |
| Skemfar Shadowsage (Extended Art) | 759 | Rare | — | — | $1.05 | $1.01 |
| Skewer the Critics (2051) (Rainbow Foil) | 2051 | Rare | — | — | $2.85 | $2.44 |
| Skewer the Critics (2056) (Raised Foil) | 2056 | Rare | — | — | $5.00 | $4.29 |
| Skirk Prospector | 2414 | Rare | — | — | $20.22 | $16.87 |
| Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon (Rainbow Foil) | 1562 | Mythic | — | — | $34.24 | $30.87 |
| Skullclamp (1663) (Rainbow Foil) | 1663 | Rare | — | — | $14.44 | $12.93 |
| Skullclamp (2416) | 2416 | Rare | — | — | $57.58 | $45.54 |
| Skyline Despot (Rainbow Foil) | 1529 | Rare | — | — | $4.99 | $4.05 |
| Slime Against Humanity (7077) | 7077 | Rare | — | — | $218.20 | $215.33 |