| Pontiff of Blight (Retro Frame) | 848 | Rare | — | — | $14.22 | $11.70 |
| Porom's Silence Magic - Silence (Rainbow Foil) | 7003 | Rare | — | — | $9.98 | $8.67 |
| Post the Enchanter - Zur the Enchanter | 726 | Rare | — | — | $26.54 | $26.20 |
| Power Sneakers - Lightning Greaves (Rainbow Foil) | 2099 | Rare | — | — | $6.88 | $5.95 |
| Predatory Sliver (Extended Art) | 654 | Rare | — | — | $8.62 | $7.66 |
| Preordain (1719) (Rainbow Foil) | 1719 | Rare | — | — | $18.99 | $16.73 |
| Preordain (2301) (Rainbow Foil) | 2301 | Rare | — | — | $8.00 | $6.04 |
| Price of Glory (Rainbow Foil) | 1525 | Rare | — | — | $32.55 | $30.96 |
| Price of Progress (Rainbow Foil) | 1521 | Rare | — | — | $21.27 | $20.00 |
| Priest of Forgotten Gods (Rainbow Foil) | 2006 | Rare | — | — | $6.55 | $5.80 |
| Primogenesis - Feed the Swarm (Rainbow Foil) | 7001 | Rare | — | — | $6.13 | $4.74 |
| Primordial Hydra | 1330 | Mythic | — | — | $15.39 | $13.77 |
| Prince of Thralls (Rainbow Foil) | 1549 | Mythic | — | — | $5.09 | $4.79 |
| Professional Face-Breaker (Rainbow Foil) | 1706 | Rare | — | — | $25.08 | $22.88 |
| Propaganda (1633) (Rainbow Foil) | 1633 | Rare | — | — | $19.99 | $16.48 |
| Propaganda (381) | 381 | Rare | — | — | $46.66 | $42.69 |
| Prosperous Innkeeper (Rainbow Foil) | 878 | Rare | — | — | $2.50 | $2.41 |
| Prossh, Skyraider of Kher (Rainbow Foil) | 1717 | Mythic | — | — | $19.99 | $16.09 |
| Protean Hulk (Foil Etched) | 319 | Rare | — | — | $16.78 | $15.22 |
| Psionic Sliver (Extended Art) | 621 | Rare | — | — | $2.16 | $1.96 |
| Psychic Corrosion (Rainbow Foil) | 1669 | Rare | — | — | $35.64 | $30.60 |
| Psychomatrix - Suture Priest | 2729 | Rare | $30.99 | — | $30.99 | — |
| Pulmonic Sliver (Extended Art) | 613 | Rare | — | — | $4.52 | $4.00 |
| Purphoros, God of the Forge | 77 | Mythic | — | — | $58.34 | $57.98 |
| Putrefy (Rainbow Foil) | 2299 | Rare | — | — | $3.01 | $2.05 |
| Qasali Slingers | 24 | Rare | — | — | $18.66 | $20.45 |
| Questing Beast (Halo Foil) | 1263 | Mythic | — | — | $14.93 | $13.89 |
| Quick Sliver (Extended Art) | 655 | Rare | — | — | $123.51 | $128.20 |
| Radha, Heart of Keld (Rainbow Foil) | 1876 | Rare | — | — | $1.02 | $0.83 |
| Rain of Filth (Rainbow Foil) | 1547 | Rare | — | — | $59.99 | $46.93 |
| Raise the Palisade (Double Rainbow Foil) | 1897 | Rare | — | — | $31.70 | $30.54 |
| Rakdos Signet (Foil Etched) | 289 | Rare | — | — | $42.35 | $38.55 |
| Ral, Storm Conduit (Stained Glass) | 523 | Promo | — | — | $1.95 | $1.66 |
| Ramunap Excavator | 2659 | Rare | — | — | $10.44 | $8.07 |
| Rankle, Master of Pranks (Rainbow Foil) | 1707 | Rare | — | — | $5.52 | $4.90 |
| Rat Colony | 36 | Rare | — | — | $15.27 | $14.54 |
| Ravenous Chupacabra (1764) (Rainbow Foil) | 1764 | Rare | — | — | $7.70 | $6.55 |
| Ravenous Chupacabra (305) (Foil Etched) | 305 | Rare | — | — | $8.08 | $7.98 |
| Ravenous Rotbelly (Retro Frame) | 849 | Rare | — | — | $2.55 | $2.42 |
| Razaketh, the Foulblooded (Foil Etched) | 163 | Mythic | — | — | $30.17 | $27.39 |
| Read the Bones (7066) (Rainbow Foil) | 7066 | Rare | — | — | $3.75 | $3.08 |
| Read the Bones (7069) (Confetti Foil) | 7069 | Rare | — | — | $7.28 | $6.06 |
| Reality Shift (Rainbow Foil) | 1781 | Rare | — | — | $8.26 | $6.95 |
| Realms Uncharted (Rainbow Foil) | 1895 | Rare | — | — | $31.74 | $30.56 |
| Realmwalker (Rainbow Foil) | 1724 | Rare | — | — | $28.30 | $26.91 |
| Reaper King | 9 | Mythic | — | — | $11.37 | $10.11 |
| Reckless Endeavor (Rainbow Foil) | 2177 | Rare | — | — | $15.25 | $14.01 |
| Reckless Fireweaver (Rainbow Foil) | 1526 | Rare | — | — | $63.50 | $49.59 |
| Reclamation Sage (Extended Art) | 777 | Rare | — | — | $0.75 | $0.60 |
| Reconnaissance (2124) | 2124 | Rare | — | — | $7.06 | $3.66 |