| Northern Paladin (Rainbow Foil) | 1855 | Rare | — | — | $1.50 | $1.10 |
| Notion Thief (Retro Frame) | 7156 | Rare | — | — | $4.95 | $3.85 |
| Nullmage Shepherd (Extended Art) | 774 | Rare | — | — | $2.32 | $1.66 |
| Number One of One - K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth | 2732 | Rare | $30.99 | — | $49.97 | $29.99 |
| Nylea, God of the Hunt | 80 | Mythic | — | — | $23.58 | $24.18 |
| Nyxbloom Ancient (Halo Foil) | 1275 | Mythic | — | — | $47.94 | $44.39 |
| Ob Nixilis, the Hate-Twisted (Stained Glass) | 511 | Promo | — | — | $4.06 | $3.94 |
| Obeka, Brute Chronologist (Rainbow Foil) | 1579 | Rare | — | — | $13.96 | $12.92 |
| Old Gnawbone (Showcase) | 1016 | Mythic | — | — | $135.56 | $118.35 |
| Olivia Voldaren (Halo Foil) | 1264 | Mythic | — | — | $10.45 | $9.85 |
| Oloro, Ageless Ascetic (Rainbow Foil) | 1962 | Mythic | — | — | $18.74 | $16.92 |
| Omnath, Locus of Creation (Rainbow Foil) | 1686 | Mythic | — | — | $7.28 | $6.93 |
| Oona, Queen of the Fae | 54 | Mythic | — | — | $15.00 | $13.43 |
| Opaline Sliver (Extended Art) | 667 | Rare | — | — | $3.26 | $3.04 |
| Open the Armory (2089) (Rainbow Foil) | 2089 | Rare | — | — | $8.15 | $7.09 |
| Opt (2068) (Rainbow Foil) | 2068 | Rare | — | — | $10.47 | $8.42 |
| Orcish Lumberjack (2025) (Rainbow Foil) | 2025 | Rare | — | — | $18.54 | $17.24 |
| Ornithopter | 604 | Rare | — | — | $20.99 | $20.48 |
| Ororo Borealis - Manamorphose (Rainbow Foil) | 1746 | Rare | — | — | $6.44 | $5.32 |
| Orvar, the All-Form (1683) (Rainbow Foil) | 1683 | Mythic | — | — | $5.67 | $4.71 |
| Orzhov Signet (Foil Etched) | 294 | Rare | — | — | $27.14 | $22.10 |
| Otherworldly Gaze (2069) (Rainbow Foil) | 2069 | Rare | — | — | $11.64 | $10.24 |
| Pack Rat (035) | 35 | Rare | — | — | $10.75 | $10.54 |
| Pack Rat (1307) (Rainbow Foil) | 1307 | Rare | — | — | $3.15 | $2.97 |
| Painful Truths (Rainbow Foil) | 2302 | Rare | — | — | $2.00 | $1.64 |
| Palladia-Mors (Stained Glass) (Textured Foil) | 1071 | Rare | — | — | $4.66 | $4.15 |
| Panharmonicon | 605 | Rare | — | — | $29.99 | $26.68 |
| Panic on Amity Island - Descent into Avernus (Rainbow Foil) | 2176 | Rare | — | — | $20.50 | $18.27 |
| Paradise Druid (Extended Art) | 775 | Rare | — | — | $2.86 | $2.51 |
| Parallax Tide | 2888 | Rare | — | — | $2.65 | $1.58 |
| Pashalik Mons | 2408 | Rare | — | — | $15.73 | $12.30 |
| Passionate Archaeologist (Rainbow Foil) | 2220 | Mythic | — | — | $18.26 | $15.48 |
| Past in Flames (Rainbow Foil) | 2303 | Mythic | — | — | $7.50 | $6.05 |
| Pastor da Selva - Ancient Greenwarden (Rainbow Foil) | 2059 | Mythic | — | — | $17.95 | $16.42 |
| Path of Ancestry (0914) (Rainbow Foil) | 914 | Rare | — | — | $33.05 | $29.25 |
| Path to Exile (2227) (Rainbow Foil) | 2227 | Rare | — | — | $23.67 | $20.75 |
| Pathbreaker Ibex (Foil Etched) | 307 | Rare | — | — | $20.00 | $18.72 |
| Patrick Star - Barktooth Warbeard (Rainbow Foil) | 1931 | Rare | — | — | $6.19 | $4.97 |
| Peek | 401 | Rare | — | — | $10.05 | $9.08 |
| Peer into the Abyss (2002) (Rainbow Foil) | 2002 | Rare | — | — | $11.88 | $8.40 |
| Peer into the Abyss (2021) (Rainbow Foil) | 2021 | Rare | — | — | $8.05 | $7.18 |
| Peregrine Drake (Rainbow Foil) | 1488 | Rare | — | — | $32.09 | $32.29 |
| Pernicious Deed (Rainbow Foil) | 1777 | Rare | — | — | $4.81 | $4.62 |
| Perplexing Chimera | 7039 | Rare | — | — | $3.30 | $2.03 |
| Persistent Petitioners (593) | 593 | Rare | — | — | $40.80 | $37.23 |
| Persistent Petitioners (595) | 595 | Rare | — | — | $540.00 | $679.99 |
| Persistent Petitioners (596) | 596 | Rare | — | — | $48.58 | $42.47 |
| Persistent Petitioners (597) | 597 | Rare | — | — | $32.99 | $30.58 |
| Persistent Petitioners (598) | 598 | Rare | — | — | $130.13 | $126.40 |
| Persistent Petitioners (599) | 599 | Rare | — | — | $19.77 | $18.13 |