| Icingdeath, Frost Tongue Token (Showcase) | 1018 | Token | — | — | $7.05 | $6.50 |
| Icingdeath, Frost Tyrant (Showcase) | 1012 | Mythic | — | — | $9.30 | $9.30 |
| Idyllic Tutor (1636) (Rainbow Foil) | 1636 | Rare | — | — | $18.93 | $18.25 |
| Ifrit - Fury (Rainbow Foil) | 7007 | Mythic | — | — | $999.50 | $751.98 |
| Ignoble Hierarch (Rainbow Foil) | 906 | Promo | — | — | $39.99 | $33.36 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-Boar (Foil Etched) | 318 | Mythic | — | — | $17.97 | $17.21 |
| Impact Tremors (1999) (Rainbow Foil) | 1999 | Rare | — | — | $10.13 | $9.89 |
| In the Trenches (Rainbow Foil) | 1729 | Mythic | — | — | $2.01 | $1.75 |
| Inalla, Archmage Ritualist (Rainbow Foil) | 1639 | Mythic | — | — | $22.57 | $19.55 |
| Indominus Rex - Polyraptor (Rainbow Foil) | 1391 | Mythic | — | — | $50.18 | $44.32 |
| Inevitable Betrayal (Rainbow Foil) | 1935 | Rare | — | — | $5.99 | $5.74 |
| Inferno of the Star Mounts (Showcase) | 1015 | Mythic | — | — | $9.12 | $7.83 |
| Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni | 33 | Rare | — | — | $15.15 | $13.83 |
| Inkshield (Rainbow Foil) | 1694 | Rare | — | — | $12.45 | $10.17 |
| Inspiring Call (Confetti Foil) | 2328 | Rare | — | — | $9.64 | $9.34 |
| Inspiring Call (Rainbow Foil) | 2313 | Rare | — | — | $8.00 | $5.88 |
| Inspiring Overseer (Rainbow Foil) | 1523 | Rare | — | — | $33.75 | $37.26 |
| Inspiring Vantage (1605) (Rainbow Foil) | 1605 | Rare | — | — | $21.36 | $20.34 |
| Intergalactic Wrestling - Possibility Storm | 7073 | Rare | — | — | $2.99 | $2.19 |
| Invasion Plans | 7107 | Rare | — | — | $5.61 | $5.60 |
| Inventors' Fair (Rainbow Foil) | 1735 | Rare | — | — | $20.97 | $18.54 |
| Iroas, God of Victory | 70 | Mythic | — | — | $32.89 | $32.42 |
| Iron Maiden (Rainbow Foil) | 2185 | Rare | — | — | $15.00 | $13.04 |
| Iron Man, Titan of Innovation (Rainbow Foil) | 1731 | Mythic | — | — | $18.54 | $16.73 |
| Island (0889) (Rainbow Foil) | 889 | Rare | — | — | $10.03 | $9.58 |
| Island (1479) (Rainbow Foil) | 1479 | Rare | — | — | $15.11 | $13.27 |
| Island (1648) (Rainbow Foil) | 1648 | Rare | — | — | $15.31 | $11.73 |
| Island (1653) (Rainbow Foil) | 1653 | Rare | — | — | $11.99 | $10.01 |
| Island (1940) (Rainbow Foil) | 1940 | Rare | — | — | $5.93 | $5.17 |
| Island (1946) (Rainbow Foil) | 1946 | Rare | — | — | $16.23 | $15.19 |
| Island (1951) (Raised Foil) | 1951 | Rare | — | — | $9.10 | $8.10 |
| Island (2077) (Rainbow Foil) | 2077 | Rare | — | — | $4.09 | $3.52 |
| Island (2144) | 2144 | Rare | — | — | $5.14 | $3.21 |
| Island (2145) | 2145 | Rare | — | — | $5.00 | $4.09 |
| Island (2146) | 2146 | Rare | — | — | $7.45 | $4.90 |
| Island (2147) | 2147 | Rare | — | — | $6.00 | $4.83 |
| Island (2755) | 2755 | Rare | $10.49 | — | $41.96 | — |
| Island (548) | 548 | Land | — | — | $1.45 | $1.37 |
| Island (549) | 549 | Land | — | — | $0.91 | $0.82 |
| Island (550) | 550 | Land | — | — | $2.97 | $2.77 |
| Island (551) | 551 | Land | — | — | $0.53 | $0.43 |
| Island (552) | 552 | Land | — | — | $2.17 | $2.17 |
| Island (553) | 553 | Land | — | — | $0.58 | $0.47 |
| Island (554) | 554 | Land | — | — | $2.19 | $2.19 |
| Island (555) | 555 | Land | — | — | $0.99 | $0.82 |
| Island (673) | 673 | Land | — | — | $18.89 | $17.19 |
| Island (Tokyo Lands) (Foil Etched) | 47 | Rare | — | — | $18.97 | $13.34 |
| Ivy Lane Denizen (Extended Art) | 769 | Rare | — | — | $7.95 | $7.57 |
| Iymrith, Desert Doom (Showcase) | 1013 | Mythic | — | — | $9.86 | $9.86 |
| Izzet Signet (Foil Etched) | 293 | Rare | — | — | $32.91 | $30.83 |