| Sauron, the Lidless Eye (Extended Art) | 396 | Mythic | $27.76 | $24.15 | — | — |
| Mithril Coat (Extended Art) | 379 | Rare | $25.78 | $23.44 | $48.10 | $43.76 |
| Mithril Coat | 245 | Rare | $23.90 | $22.49 | $28.99 | $23.95 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff (Showcase Scrolls) | 664 | Rare | $24.85 | $21.88 | $53.68 | $55.58 |
| Delighted Halfling | 158 | Rare | $24.14 | $21.86 | $27.95 | $23.71 |
| Last March of the Ents (Borderless) | 418 | Mythic | $22.49 | $21.10 | $27.99 | $24.36 |
| Last March of the Ents | 172 | Mythic | $21.74 | $19.69 | $26.43 | $23.81 |
| Palantir of Orthanc (Extended Art) | 381 | Mythic | $22.99 | $19.52 | $51.09 | $48.07 |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin (Extended Art) | 391 | Rare | $19.63 | $19.11 | — | — |
| Nazgul (0334) | 334 | Uncommon | $20.50 | $18.86 | $40.19 | $40.19 |
| Call of the Ring (Showcase Scrolls) | 530 | Rare | $22.73 | $18.68 | $49.99 | $34.41 |
| Flowering of the White Tree (Showcase Scrolls) | 466 | Rare | $19.65 | $17.98 | $22.75 | $22.73 |
| Spiteful Banditry (Showcase Scrolls) | 600 | Mythic | $21.31 | $17.60 | $45.49 | $26.31 |
| Aragorn, the Uniter (Showcase Scrolls) | 643 | Mythic | $18.98 | $17.49 | $32.49 | $26.97 |
| Nazgul (0336) | 336 | Uncommon | $19.20 | $16.93 | $29.19 | $28.46 |
| Nazgul (0100) | 100 | Uncommon | $18.00 | $16.65 | $36.99 | $35.17 |
| Nazgul (0333) | 333 | Uncommon | $17.98 | $16.54 | $37.64 | $37.54 |
| Nazgul (0332) | 332 | Uncommon | $18.33 | $16.50 | $29.30 | $29.30 |
| Nazgul (0337) | 337 | Uncommon | $17.99 | $16.49 | $31.99 | $33.19 |
| Anduril, Flame of the West (Showcase Scrolls) | 687 | Mythic | $17.47 | $16.43 | $33.74 | $21.61 |
| One Ring to Rule Them All (Showcase Scrolls) | 553 | Rare | $16.90 | $16.37 | $24.21 | $20.05 |
| Gandalf the White (Borderless) | 442 | Mythic | $16.31 | $16.22 | $23.04 | $23.49 |
| Nazgul (0335) | 335 | Uncommon | $19.23 | $16.11 | $42.37 | $43.07 |
| Nazgul (0338) | 338 | Uncommon | $17.65 | $15.69 | $43.60 | $43.40 |
| Nazgul (0339) | 339 | Uncommon | $19.20 | $15.51 | $36.89 | $35.63 |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower (Showcase Scrolls) | 455 | Rare | $16.99 | $15.08 | $29.76 | $24.15 |
| Palantir of Orthanc | 247 | Mythic | $16.08 | $15.02 | $22.52 | $20.52 |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord (Showcase) | 329 | Mythic | $16.07 | $14.63 | $22.96 | $19.59 |
| Borne Upon a Wind (Showcase Scrolls) | 495 | Rare | $15.00 | $14.60 | $30.57 | $30.57 |
| Bilbo's Ring (Extended Art) | 397 | Rare | $16.00 | $14.32 | — | — |
| Gandalf the White (Showcase) | 305 | Mythic | $14.91 | $14.14 | $22.03 | $20.03 |
| Witch-king of Angmar (Borderless) | 423 | Mythic | $16.62 | $14.01 | $24.99 | $23.23 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen (Showcase Scrolls) | 644 | Mythic | $15.18 | $13.78 | $20.52 | $18.99 |
| Lorien Revealed (Showcase Scrolls) | 511 | Common | $15.00 | $13.48 | $22.61 | $21.08 |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord | 224 | Mythic | $14.89 | $13.37 | $30.95 | $28.49 |
| The Watcher in the Water (Showcase Scrolls) | 526 | Mythic | $15.99 | $12.76 | $23.97 | $17.23 |
| Gloin, Dwarf Emissary (Showcase Scrolls) | 583 | Rare | $15.87 | $12.73 | $15.99 | $15.97 |
| Bilbo's Ring | 298 | Rare | $12.84 | $12.15 | — | — |
| Storm of Saruman (Showcase Scrolls) | 523 | Mythic | $13.28 | $11.89 | $18.43 | $15.52 |
| Witch-king of Angmar (Showcase) | 311 | Mythic | $12.53 | $11.82 | $18.10 | $17.83 |
| Gandalf, White Rider (Extended Art) | 389 | Rare | $13.94 | $11.73 | — | — |
| Elanor Gardner (Extended Art) | 387 | Rare | $11.30 | $11.29 | — | — |
| Shelob, Child of Ungoliant (Showcase Scrolls) | 681 | Rare | $12.00 | $11.29 | $18.82 | $19.15 |
| Galadriel, Gift-Giver (Extended Art) | 393 | Rare | $11.47 | $11.14 | — | — |
| Ringwraiths (Extended Art) | 385 | Rare | $11.01 | $11.01 | — | — |
| Aragorn, the Uniter (Borderless) | 434 | Mythic | $10.92 | $10.65 | $16.87 | $15.87 |
| Forge Anew (Showcase Scrolls) | 468 | Rare | $13.31 | $10.62 | $13.23 | $11.96 |
| Flame of Anor (Showcase Scrolls) | 654 | Rare | $11.27 | $10.34 | $13.72 | $13.21 |
| Sting, the Glinting Dagger (Showcase Scrolls) | 701 | Rare | $12.13 | $10.12 | $20.23 | $17.02 |
| Flowering of the White Tree (Extended Art) | 348 | Rare | $10.93 | $10.04 | — | — |