| Cast into the Fire (Showcase Scrolls) | 569 | Common | $4.96 | $4.81 | $8.05 | $7.86 |
| Storm of Saruman (Borderless) | 413 | Mythic | $5.18 | $4.79 | $7.08 | $7.08 |
| Gandalf the Grey (Showcase Scrolls) | 658 | Rare | $6.12 | $4.69 | $6.23 | $5.75 |
| Forge Anew (Extended Art) | 349 | Rare | $5.45 | $4.68 | $9.06 | $7.96 |
| Scroll of Isildur (Showcase Scrolls) | 520 | Rare | $5.26 | $4.60 | $7.19 | $6.95 |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower | 4 | Rare | $5.00 | $4.53 | $5.77 | $5.37 |
| Hew the Entwood (Showcase Scrolls) | 587 | Mythic | $5.95 | $4.49 | $7.49 | $6.31 |
| Press the Enemy (Showcase Scrolls) | 516 | Rare | $5.16 | $4.45 | $5.49 | $5.16 |
| Elven Chorus (Extended Art) | 364 | Rare | $5.06 | $4.41 | — | — |
| Smeagol, Helpful Guide (Showcase Scrolls) | 682 | Rare | $5.18 | $4.33 | $7.46 | $7.46 |
| Elvish Mariner (Extended Art) | 384 | Rare | $4.23 | $4.32 | — | — |
| Fiery Inscription (Showcase Scrolls) | 577 | Uncommon | $4.71 | $4.20 | $5.89 | $5.29 |
| Dawn of a New Age (Extended Art) | 347 | Mythic | $4.34 | $4.11 | $1.00 | — |
| Barad-dur (0425) (Borderless) | 425 | Rare | $4.22 | $4.04 | $6.13 | $5.88 |
| Peregrin Took (Showcase Scrolls) | 632 | Uncommon | $4.04 | $4.04 | $5.48 | $4.98 |
| Mauhur, Uruk-hai Captain (Showcase Scrolls) | 665 | Uncommon | $4.01 | $3.98 | $8.00 | $8.05 |
| The Battle of Bywater (Extended Art) | 346 | Rare | $3.91 | $3.96 | — | — |
| Gandalf, Friend of the Shire (Borderless) | 401 | Promo | $3.70 | $3.95 | $3.61 | $3.69 |
| Elanor Gardner | 286 | Rare | $4.24 | $3.93 | $9.99 | $10.58 |
| Forge Anew | 17 | Rare | $4.36 | $3.91 | $5.97 | $5.65 |
| Legolas, Master Archer (Showcase Scrolls) | 624 | Rare | $3.86 | $3.86 | $4.79 | $3.15 |
| Frodo, Determined Hero (Extended Art) | 388 | Rare | $3.85 | $3.85 | — | — |
| Ringsight (Showcase Scrolls) | 671 | Uncommon | $3.99 | $3.83 | $4.18 | $4.11 |
| Call of the Ring | 79 | Rare | $3.98 | $3.81 | $5.85 | $4.91 |
| Ioreth of the Healing House (Showcase Scrolls) | 507 | Uncommon | $3.98 | $3.80 | $7.43 | $6.85 |
| The Watcher in the Water (Extended Art) | 354 | Mythic | $4.07 | $3.77 | — | — |
| King of the Oathbreakers (Showcase Scrolls) | 662 | Rare | $3.96 | $3.75 | $5.99 | $4.21 |
| Borne Upon a Wind (Extended Art) | 350 | Rare | $4.86 | $3.73 | — | — |
| Flame of Anor (Borderless) | 406 | Rare | $4.00 | $3.62 | $5.69 | $4.81 |
| Sauron's Ransom (Showcase Scrolls) | 676 | Rare | $4.79 | $3.57 | $8.07 | $5.82 |
| Elven Chorus | 160 | Rare | $3.99 | $3.54 | $4.91 | $4.45 |
| Rise of the Witch-king (Showcase Scrolls) | 672 | Uncommon | $3.66 | $3.52 | $4.32 | $3.93 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen | 193 | Mythic | $4.09 | $3.50 | $7.50 | $6.96 |
| Fires of Mount Doom (Extended Art) | 392 | Rare | $3.67 | $3.48 | — | — |
| Glamdring (Extended Art) | 376 | Mythic | $3.67 | $3.48 | — | — |
| Gollum, Scheming Guide (Extended Art) | 390 | Rare | $3.64 | $3.45 | — | — |
| Reprieve (Showcase Scrolls) | 477 | Uncommon | $3.47 | $3.39 | $4.60 | $4.20 |
| Aragorn, the Uniter | 192 | Mythic | $4.07 | $3.38 | $7.72 | $7.65 |
| Horn of Gondor (Extended Art) | 377 | Rare | $3.15 | $3.35 | $6.47 | $6.10 |
| Galadriel of Lothlorien (Showcase Scrolls) | 657 | Rare | $3.33 | $3.22 | $3.75 | $2.96 |
| Doors of Durin (Showcase Scrolls) | 650 | Rare | $3.70 | $3.05 | $5.38 | $4.81 |
| Phial of Galadriel (Showcase Scrolls) | 699 | Rare | $3.46 | $2.99 | $6.49 | $6.34 |
| Dawn of a New Age | 5 | Mythic | $3.10 | $2.96 | $4.03 | $3.65 |
| Lorien Revealed | 60 | Common | $3.73 | $2.96 | $5.01 | $4.89 |
| Frodo, Sauron's Bane (Showcase Scrolls) | 469 | Rare | $2.95 | $2.95 | $3.98 | $3.10 |
| Anduril, Flame of the West | 236 | Mythic | $3.15 | $2.94 | $6.17 | $6.04 |
| Barad-dur (0340) (Borderless) | 340 | Rare | $3.20 | $2.94 | $4.81 | $4.06 |
| Gollum, Scheming Guide | 292 | Rare | $2.89 | $2.90 | — | — |
| Sting, the Glinting Dagger | 250 | Rare | $3.00 | $2.88 | $4.50 | $4.32 |
| Storm of Saruman | 72 | Mythic | $3.04 | $2.88 | $4.93 | $4.93 |