| Samwise Gamgee (Showcase Scrolls) | 673 | Rare | $9.21 | $9.01 | $18.96 | $17.35 |
| Minas Tirith (Showcase Scrolls) | 707 | Rare | $9.08 | $8.81 | $11.37 | $10.03 |
| Gandalf, White Rider | 290 | Rare | $8.53 | $8.50 | — | — |
| Riders of the Mark (Extended Art) | 832 | Rare | $8.64 | $8.47 | — | — |
| Flowering of the White Tree | 15 | Rare | $7.97 | $8.11 | $10.30 | $9.42 |
| Entish Restoration (Showcase Scrolls) | 614 | Uncommon | $8.01 | $7.97 | $9.99 | $8.89 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | 213 | Rare | $8.55 | $7.92 | $10.60 | $9.96 |
| Saruman of Many Colors (Borderless) | 412 | Mythic | $7.36 | $7.50 | $10.92 | $10.99 |
| Shadow of the Enemy (Showcase Scrolls) | 558 | Mythic | $8.26 | $7.49 | $14.39 | $13.15 |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin | 293 | Rare | $8.49 | $7.49 | — | — |
| Mount Doom (Borderless) | 343 | Mythic | $8.31 | $7.45 | $10.94 | $10.34 |
| The Battle of Bywater (Showcase Scrolls) | 453 | Rare | $7.80 | $7.43 | $11.69 | $9.10 |
| Gandalf the White | 19 | Mythic | $8.13 | $7.40 | $12.00 | $11.98 |
| Mount Doom | 258 | Mythic | $7.38 | $7.38 | $10.11 | $8.97 |
| Spiteful Banditry (Borderless) | 439 | Mythic | $7.58 | $7.21 | $8.93 | $8.48 |
| Galadriel, Gift-Giver | 296 | Rare | $7.44 | $7.20 | — | — |
| Riders of the Mark | 827 | Rare | $8.00 | $7.19 | — | — |
| Lembas (Showcase Scrolls) | 694 | Common | $7.00 | $6.99 | $8.43 | $8.42 |
| Spiteful Banditry | 149 | Mythic | $7.29 | $6.86 | $9.65 | $9.60 |
| Aragorn, the Uniter (Showcase) | 317 | Mythic | $7.31 | $6.67 | $12.38 | $12.08 |
| Mirkwood Bats (Showcase Scrolls) | 546 | Common | $7.12 | $6.66 | $8.80 | $8.28 |
| War of the Last Alliance (Showcase Scrolls) | 487 | Rare | $7.85 | $6.54 | $10.00 | $9.05 |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower (Borderless) | 407 | Rare | $6.70 | $6.53 | $10.86 | $10.61 |
| Goldberry, River-Daughter (Showcase Scrolls) | 503 | Rare | $6.99 | $6.47 | $8.64 | $7.41 |
| Mines of Moria (Showcase Scrolls) | 708 | Rare | $8.06 | $6.43 | $8.94 | $8.15 |
| Witch-king of Angmar | 114 | Mythic | $6.59 | $6.42 | $10.83 | $10.87 |
| Gloin, Dwarf Emissary (Extended Art) | 360 | Rare | $6.39 | $6.39 | — | — |
| Sauron, the Necromancer (Showcase Scrolls) | 557 | Rare | $6.51 | $6.24 | $8.68 | $8.68 |
| Minas Tirith (0420) (Borderless) | 420 | Rare | $6.68 | $6.18 | $8.69 | $8.90 |
| Barad-dur (Showcase Scrolls) | 704 | Rare | $8.93 | $6.05 | $10.95 | $6.77 |
| Horn of Gondor (Showcase Scrolls) | 691 | Rare | $6.45 | $6.04 | $8.64 | $8.41 |
| There and Back Again | 151 | Rare | $6.34 | $6.03 | $9.96 | $8.88 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen (Extended Art) | 367 | Mythic | $6.63 | $5.98 | $31.56 | $29.22 |
| Minas Tirith (0341) (Borderless) | 341 | Rare | $6.60 | $5.98 | $8.99 | $8.69 |
| The Shire (Showcase Scrolls) | 711 | Rare | $6.96 | $5.71 | $8.04 | $7.92 |
| Troll of Khazad-dum (Showcase Scrolls) | 562 | Common | $5.88 | $5.66 | $8.70 | $7.32 |
| Radagast the Brown (Showcase Scrolls) | 635 | Mythic | $5.99 | $5.53 | $9.21 | $7.55 |
| The Balrog, Durin's Bane (Showcase Scrolls) | 646 | Rare | $5.99 | $5.52 | $6.69 | $5.33 |
| Rivendell (Showcase Scrolls) | 710 | Rare | $6.61 | $5.47 | $9.41 | $8.52 |
| Anduril, Flame of the West (Extended Art) | 375 | Mythic | $5.68 | $5.41 | $17.73 | $16.76 |
| Call of the Ring (Extended Art) | 355 | Rare | $5.71 | $5.38 | $11.18 | $10.60 |
| Minas Tirith | 256 | Rare | $5.80 | $5.32 | $6.63 | $6.29 |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower (Showcase) | 302 | Rare | $5.83 | $5.30 | $7.67 | $7.51 |
| Assault on Osgiliath (Extended Art) | 386 | Rare | $5.30 | $5.15 | — | — |