| Spiteful Banditry (Borderless Poster) | 738 | Mythic | $92.44 | $96.21 | $196.65 | $161.36 |
| Storm of Saruman (Borderless Poster) | 733 | Mythic | $89.99 | $83.34 | $155.00 | $154.41 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen (Borderless Poster) | 742 | Mythic | $101.03 | $83.26 | $153.99 | $136.56 |
| The Watcher in the Water (Borderless Poster) | 734 | Mythic | $91.02 | $72.22 | $155.22 | $152.29 |
| Mithril Coat (Showcase Scrolls) | 696 | Rare | $62.97 | $62.94 | $72.99 | $72.59 |
| Shadow of the Enemy (Borderless Poster) | 735 | Mythic | $71.75 | $62.31 | $129.14 | $105.48 |
| Palantir of Orthanc (Showcase Scrolls) | 698 | Mythic | $53.34 | $50.78 | $64.75 | $62.57 |
| Last March of the Ents (Showcase Scrolls) | 623 | Mythic | $54.59 | $46.90 | $64.21 | $62.67 |
| Delighted Halfling (Showcase Scrolls) | 609 | Rare | $51.59 | $45.32 | $94.06 | $81.16 |
| Dawn of a New Age (Borderless Poster) | 731 | Mythic | $44.02 | $42.96 | $100.00 | $98.60 |
| Orcish Bowmasters (Borderless) | 433 | Rare | $48.89 | $41.79 | $60.00 | $56.13 |
| Warg Rider | 826 | Rare | $39.88 | $38.89 | — | — |
| Warg Rider (Extended Art) | 831 | Rare | $40.35 | $37.77 | — | — |
| There and Back Again (Showcase Scrolls) | 602 | Rare | $44.95 | $37.20 | $50.14 | $49.92 |
| Orcish Bowmasters | 103 | Rare | $41.50 | $36.63 | $47.77 | $43.94 |
| Witch-king of Angmar (Showcase Scrolls) | 565 | Mythic | $46.98 | $33.19 | $61.05 | $52.71 |
| Hew the Entwood (Borderless Poster) | 737 | Mythic | $61.06 | $31.92 | $74.31 | $74.31 |
| Tom Bombadil (Showcase Scrolls) | 685 | Mythic | $28.30 | $26.70 | $41.90 | $38.86 |
| Gandalf the White (Showcase Scrolls) | 470 | Mythic | $38.58 | $25.84 | $89.98 | $52.84 |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed (Extended Art) | 394 | Mythic | $27.40 | $25.57 | — | — |
| Delighted Halfling (Extended Art) | 363 | Rare | $28.69 | $25.51 | — | — |
| Mount Doom (Showcase Scrolls) | 709 | Mythic | $29.30 | $25.08 | $42.30 | $32.25 |
| Delighted Halfling (Borderless) | 402 | Promo | $30.97 | $24.33 | $30.00 | $29.03 |
| Sauron, the Lidless Eye (Extended Art) | 396 | Mythic | $27.76 | $24.15 | — | — |
| Mithril Coat (Extended Art) | 379 | Rare | $25.78 | $23.44 | $48.10 | $43.76 |
| Mithril Coat | 245 | Rare | $23.90 | $22.49 | $28.99 | $23.95 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff (Showcase Scrolls) | 664 | Rare | $24.85 | $21.88 | $53.68 | $55.58 |
| Delighted Halfling | 158 | Rare | $24.14 | $21.86 | $27.95 | $23.71 |
| Last March of the Ents (Borderless) | 418 | Mythic | $22.49 | $21.10 | $27.99 | $24.36 |