| Thorin, Company's Leader (Extended Art) | 100 | Mythic | $23.91 | $19.69 | — | — |
| Chief of the Wilds (Extended Art) | 103 | Mythic | $19.12 | $17.32 | — | — |
| Great Goblin, Foul-Hearted (Extended Art) | 105 | Mythic | $17.05 | $16.01 | — | — |
| Call Forth the Tempest (Borderless) | 22 | Mythic | $18.09 | $15.97 | $20.00 | $17.20 |
| Smaug the Impenetrable (Borderless) | 9 | Rare | $15.29 | $14.42 | $15.84 | $14.36 |
| Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress (Borderless) | 48 | Mythic | $14.48 | $13.51 | $15.01 | $13.41 |
| Flowering of the White Tree (Borderless) | 14 | Mythic | $14.81 | $13.38 | $17.43 | $16.60 |
| Relic of Sauron (Borderless) | 46 | Mythic | $13.58 | $13.30 | $18.06 | $16.47 |
| The Black Gate (Borderless) | 47 | Mythic | $13.10 | $12.46 | $13.80 | $13.14 |
| Necklace of Girion (Borderless) | 12 | Rare | $14.00 | $12.15 | $15.15 | $13.26 |
| Raise the Palisade (Borderless) | 18 | Mythic | $12.24 | $11.42 | $12.58 | $12.35 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff (Borderless) | 34 | Mythic | $12.78 | $11.37 | $15.44 | $13.42 |
| Witch-king of Angmar (Borderless) | 20 | Mythic | $13.22 | $11.23 | $15.23 | $13.58 |
| Arwen, Weaver of Hope (Borderless) | 24 | Mythic | $11.99 | $10.86 | $14.20 | $12.86 |
| Anduril, Narsil Reforged (Borderless) | 40 | Mythic | $11.69 | $10.32 | $12.78 | $11.40 |
| Bard, Heir of Girion (Extended Art) | 101 | Mythic | $9.68 | $9.60 | — | — |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin (Borderless) | 21 | Mythic | $11.01 | $9.57 | $11.24 | $9.57 |
| Minas Tirith (Borderless) | 49 | Mythic | $9.17 | $9.17 | $11.50 | $11.24 |
| Mount Doom (Borderless) | 50 | Mythic | $9.05 | $8.75 | $12.72 | $11.62 |
| Elvish Archdruid | 204 | Rare | $10.29 | $8.63 | — | — |
| Shadow of the Enemy | 190 | Mythic | $8.99 | $8.62 | — | — |
| Inferno Titan | 198 | Mythic | $8.51 | $8.51 | — | — |
| Dwarven Warriors (Borderless) (Dwarvish) | 93 | Mythic | $10.01 | $8.45 | $19.99 | $16.68 |
| Bilbo's Ring (Borderless) | 41 | Mythic | $8.99 | $8.31 | $9.25 | $8.30 |
| Dawn of a New Age | 162 | Mythic | $8.17 | $8.17 | — | — |
| Tom Bombadil (Borderless) | 38 | Mythic | $9.41 | $7.80 | $10.68 | $8.66 |
| Bolg, Erebor's Reckoning (Extended Art) | 102 | Mythic | $8.90 | $7.72 | — | — |
| The Gaffer (Borderless) | 15 | Mythic | $7.63 | $7.64 | $8.00 | $7.48 |
| Languish | 187 | Rare | $7.30 | $7.63 | — | — |
| Elven Chorus (Borderless) | 26 | Mythic | $8.15 | $7.54 | $8.79 | $7.99 |
| Orcish Siegemaster | 201 | Rare | $7.46 | $7.49 | — | — |
| Troll of Khazad-dum | 191 | Common | $10.12 | $7.28 | — | — |
| Bilbo, Fellow Conspirator (Borderless) | 4 | Rare | $7.45 | $7.26 | $7.60 | $6.15 |
| Night's Whisper | 189 | Common | $8.70 | $7.15 | — | — |
| Lorien Revealed | 179 | Common | $8.71 | $6.87 | — | — |
| Aragorn, the Uniter (Borderless) | 29 | Mythic | $7.71 | $6.68 | $8.16 | $6.79 |
| Bilbo, Unexpected Adventurer (Extended Art) | 98 | Mythic | $7.80 | $6.65 | — | — |
| Flame of Anor (Borderless) | 31 | Mythic | $6.88 | $6.39 | $7.52 | $6.49 |
| Wayfarer's Bauble | 211 | Common | $7.65 | $6.18 | — | — |
| Mirkwood Elk | 210 | Rare | $7.43 | $6.12 | — | — |
| Dragon-Cursed Halls (Borderless) | 8 | Rare | $6.25 | $5.56 | $7.00 | $6.75 |
| Reprieve (Borderless) | 17 | Mythic | $5.88 | $5.32 | $6.75 | $6.73 |
| Bag End Banquet (Borderless) | 5 | Rare | $5.88 | $5.30 | $6.77 | $5.36 |
| Elvish Mystic | 205 | Common | $5.31 | $5.21 | — | — |
| Ori, Plate Stacker (Borderless) | 6 | Rare | $4.95 | $5.17 | $4.78 | $4.38 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen (Borderless) | 30 | Mythic | $5.57 | $5.05 | $5.60 | $5.33 |